Few villains in film history are as famous as the Joker. Since his first appearance in Batman comics in 1940, the Clown Prince of Crime has been played by some of the greatest actors of every generation, and every one of them has brought something different to the role. Some played him for laughs, some for terror, and one turned him into an Oscar-winning portrait of a broken man. This is every major actor who played the Joker on screen, ranked from weakest to best, based on the performance itself, the impact of the film, and how the portrayal has lasted in pop culture.

8. Jared Leto – Suicide Squad (2016)
Jared Leto’s Joker is the most divisive version ever put on screen. Tattooed, gangster-styled and barely in the film, his Joker felt more like a modern crime boss than the chaotic trickster fans expected. Leto reportedly stayed in character throughout filming and sent strange gifts to his co-stars, but the performance itself was cut down to a few short scenes in Suicide Squad. There are flashes of menace, especially opposite Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn, yet the version never got the screen time or the story to make its mark. It ranks last because it is the least memorable Joker, not because Leto lacks talent.
7. Barry Keoghan – The Batman (2022)
Barry Keoghan’s Joker appears for only a few minutes at the end of The Batman, in a prison cell opposite Paul Dano’s Riddler. It is a cameo, not a full performance, so ranking him higher would be unfair to the actors who carried whole films. What we do see is unsettling: a scarred, giggling figure who already understands Batman better than anyone else. Keoghan has the potential to climb this list in a future film, but for now he is a promise rather than a complete Joker.
6. Cesar Romero – Batman (1966) and the 1960s TV Series
Cesar Romero was the first actor to play the Joker in live action, and he did it with a grin, a laugh and a moustache he famously refused to shave off, even under the white face paint. His Joker was pure camp: a prankster who plotted crimes with oversized props, henchmen and elaborate traps. It is easy to laugh at the 1960s version now, but Romero set the template for the character on screen, and his joyful, theatrical energy is still part of every Joker that followed. He ranks in the middle because the performance is fun but light, with none of the menace later versions brought to the role.
5. Cameron Monaghan – Gotham (2014-2019)
Cameron Monaghan played not one but two Joker figures on the TV series Gotham: the twins Jerome and Jeremiah Valeska. Jerome was wild, giggling and unpredictable, while Jeremiah was colder and more calculating. Together they gave the show a Joker in all but name, and Monaghan threw himself into both roles with impressive energy. His work is the best small-screen Joker so far, and the reason he sits above Romero is the sheer range he showed across five seasons. The only thing holding him back is that Gotham was never allowed to call him the Joker outright.
4. Jack Nicholson – Batman (1989)
Jack Nicholson turned the Joker into a box-office event. In Tim Burton’s Batman, his Jack Napier is a gangster who falls into chemicals and emerges as a grinning, murderous showman. Nicholson’s Joker is funny, frightening and completely in control of every scene he is in, and his star power helped make Batman the biggest film of 1989. His version defined the character for a generation of moviegoers, and his laugh and his one-liners are still quoted today. He falls just short of the top three because later actors found more darkness and depth in the character.
3. Joaquin Phoenix – Joker (2019)
Joaquin Phoenix won the Academy Award for Best Actor for his portrayal of Arthur Fleck, a struggling comedian who slowly becomes the Joker. It is the most grounded version of the character ever filmed: there is no Batman, no cape, and no supervillain plot, just a man failed by the city around him. Phoenix lost a dramatic amount of weight for the role, developed the character’s painful, uncontrollable laugh, and carried the entire film on his shoulders. Joker became the first R-rated film to earn more than a billion dollars at the box office, and it proved the character could work as serious drama. It ranks third because, brilliant as it is, it is more a character study than a classic Joker story.
2. Mark Hamill – Batman: The Animated Series (1992-1995) and Beyond
Mark Hamill may be best known as Luke Skywalker, but for millions of fans he is the voice of the Joker. His performance in Batman: The Animated Series set the standard for the character: playful one moment, terrifying the next, with a laugh that is instantly recognisable. Hamill voiced the Joker for more than thirty years, in animated series, films and video games including the Arkham games, and his version is the one many fans hear when they read the comics. Voice acting rarely gets the credit it deserves, but Hamill’s Joker is so complete that he comes within a whisker of the top spot.
1. Heath Ledger – The Dark Knight (2008)
Heath Ledger’s Joker is not just the best version of the character, it is one of the greatest villain performances in cinema history. Ledger’s Joker has no origin story, no plan beyond chaos, and no interest in money or power. He simply wants to watch the world burn, and he does it with a terrifying calm, a smeared smile and a voice that shifts between whisper and snarl. Ledger won a posthumous Academy Award for the role, and his performance redefined what a comic-book villain could be. Every Joker since has been measured against him, and none has matched him yet. That is why Heath Ledger is number one.

What Makes a Great Joker?
The best Jokers share three qualities. First, unpredictability: you should never know what the Joker will do next. Second, a twisted sense of humour that makes the audience laugh even as they feel uncomfortable. Third, a real connection to Batman, because the Joker only matters as the dark mirror of the hero. Ledger had all three in abundance, Hamill mastered them with his voice alone, and Phoenix found them in a character study rather than a comic-book film.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who played the Joker best?
Heath Ledger is widely regarded as the best Joker, winning a posthumous Oscar for The Dark Knight. Mark Hamill’s animated version and Joaquin Phoenix’s Oscar-winning Joker are the closest challengers.
How many actors have played the Joker in live action?
Six actors have played the Joker in major live-action films: Cesar Romero, Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger, Jared Leto, Joaquin Phoenix and Barry Keoghan, with Cameron Monaghan playing the Joker’s predecessors on TV’s Gotham and Mark Hamill defining the animated version.
Will the Joker return in The Batman Part II?
Barry Keoghan’s Joker is expected to return in a bigger role in the sequel to The Batman, though no official details about the story have been confirmed yet.
Final Thoughts
Every actor who played the Joker brought something new to the role, from Romero’s joyful camp to Ledger’s terrifying chaos and Phoenix’s heartbreaking realism. That is why the character has lasted for more than eighty years: the Joker can be funny, frightening, tragic or all three at once, depending on who is wearing the smile. For now, Heath Ledger remains the definitive Joker, but the next great version may already be waiting in the wings.










Pingback: What's New: Star Wars Timeline, Joker & Fantasy TV
Pingback: Robert Pattinson James Bond: New 007 Announced (2026)